Old Apples
A Washington apple can spend most of a year in cold, low-oxygen storage before it reaches the shelf. What that does to it, starting from my dad’s produce stand.

I grew up in the produce business. My dad was a baker by trade when he was younger. One day, when I was really young (too young to remember it), he had an accident with some industrial baking machinery and lost his index finger. That was the end of his professional baking career. So he started selling produce, wholesale and retail, and he sold apples all year round, as far as I can remember.
I don’t know what he knew about apples, and he’s not around anymore to ask.
I grew up in San Jose. What I knew about Washington was apples, cherries, and any other fruit I saw with “Washington” printed on the box.
I often avoid apples just before apple season, because they seem to rot so quickly or sometimes have a weird texture.
I don’t like old apples.
I think they get gritty or grainy. Sometimes they lose their crispness.
Where the old apples come from
Washington picks its apples from August to the end of November. About 40 percent of a year’s crop is sold by December 1, most of it straight from the orchard to the store.
The other 60 percent goes to market over the next eight months.
So an apple on the shelf in July may have been picked the fall before.
What keeps it is a sealed room. In controlled-atmosphere storage, the oxygen in the air is cut from about 21 percent to as low as 1 percent, depending on the variety, and the fruit is held between 32 and 34 degrees Fahrenheit. Many varieties keep for 12 months or more that way. Washington has more of this storage than any other growing region in the world. Most of its controlled-atmosphere apples ship between January and September.
There is a second treatment, too. A compound called 1-MCP, sold as SmartFresh and registered in the United States in 2002, blocks ethylene, the gas that tells fruit to ripen. In USDA trials, treated apples in controlled-atmosphere storage stayed firm three to six months longer than untreated ones.
None of this is new. Kidd and West, at the Low Temperature Research Station in Cambridge, England, started working on what they called gas storage in the 1910s. By 1937, England had 29 million cubic feet of it. Robert Smock went to Cambridge to see their work in the late 1930s, and he and his students at Cornell spent the 1940s and 1950s making it work for American growers.
Washington came late. A USDA report in 1957 noted that no controlled-atmosphere storage for apples had been built in the Pacific Northwest. The first came to Washington that year.
The apples I avoid
By late summer, the storage apples left are the ones that have been held longest. Long storage has costs.
Every variety will eventually develop senescent breakdown, an aging disorder, if it is stored long enough. Mealiness is another. In a crisp apple, a bite breaks the cells open. In a mealy one, the cells come apart whole, and the flesh is soft, dry and sandy. In one study, mealiness rose sharply between two and four months of cold storage.
What the research does not show is that a stored apple goes bad faster once it comes out. Most of it points the other way. A 1957 USDA study of Delicious apples found that fruit from controlled-atmosphere storage lasted longer on the market shelf than fruit from ordinary cold storage. A 2001 study at Massey University in New Zealand found that controlled-atmosphere storage had little effect on how fast apples softened afterward. In USDA trials, Red Delicious treated with 1-MCP stayed crunchier for two to three weeks longer after leaving storage.
The late-summer shelf isn’t all storage fruit, either. Imported apples, mostly from Chile and New Zealand, arrive in late spring and summer. They were picked in February or March. The first new-crop Washington apples, Gala and Honeycrisp among them, come off the trees in August, and some early varieties soften quickly after harvest.
So the apple I don’t like in August could be one of the oldest in the store. Or one of the newest.

Counting a crop you’re still picking
Washington grows more than 100 million boxes of apples a year. Until this year, the Washington State Tree Fruit Association published a crop forecast on August 1. Its forecasts usually missed by 5 to 7 percent, usually on the high side, and the miss alone was larger than most states’ entire crops.
This year the association stopped. Its board ended the August forecast, the five-year forecast and the October and November storage reports. Its president, Jon DeVaney, said there were too many variables to make a prediction, and that “the decision to pick or not pick is increasingly being influenced by labor supply” and economic conditions.
The first numbers now come out December 1, after harvest.
Back at the stand
I remember his apples being fresh and crisp. Not always. It’s been a long time.
Now I go by what I get from Costco or the supermarket.

Local apple farms are the best, though. Right off the tree, like in Snohomish, at the annual apple festivals.
Sources and further reading
- Apple Storage Backgrounder. USApple, for the 40 percent sold by December 1 and the rest over eight months, and Cornell’s work in the 1930s.
- Controlled Atmosphere Storage. Northwest Horticultural Council, for the oxygen levels, temperatures, 12-month storage, Washington’s capacity and the January-to-September shipping window.
- WA tree fruit association discontinues apple forecasts, but quality looks good so far. Questen Inghram, Yakima Herald-Republic, in The Spokesman-Review, September 24, 2026, for the end of the forecasts, the 5 to 7 percent miss, the December 1 report and harvest dates.
- Robert Smock and the Diffusion of Controlled Atmosphere Technology in the U.S. Apple Industry, 1940-1960. John M. Love, Cornell staff paper, 1988, for Kidd and West, England’s capacity in 1937, Smock, and 1957 in Washington.
- Controlled-Atmosphere Storage of Starking Delicious Apples in the Pacific Northwest. USDA, 1957, for the shelf life of controlled-atmosphere fruit and the state of storage in the Northwest that year.
- SmartFresh registration. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, July 17, 2002.
- ARS-Studied Gas Helps Apples Stay Crisp. USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2007, for how 1-MCP works and how long treated apples stayed firm.
- Storage Disorders. University of Maine Cooperative Extension, for senescent breakdown.
- Mealiness in apple. Segonne and others, BMC Plant Biology, 2014, for cell separation and the rise between two and four months.
- Postharvest Apple Softening. J. W. Johnston, Massey University, 2001, for softening after storage and early varieties.
- Shoppers demand apples year-round. Produce Business, 2022, for imports from Chile and New Zealand and when they arrive.
- Sage Fruit reports on Washington apple harvest. Perishable News, 2020, for Gala and Honeycrisp coming off first.